War Coverage Compared

How far the versions diverge

Every card with versions from at least two source groups is labelled with how far they diverge.

By level

Not labelled: 149 (only one group’s version, or no label set).

By topic: where contradictions are most frequent

TopicLabelledAgreeDetailsContradictShare contradicting
Ports and shipping18081056%
Donetsk region and Donbas24481250%
Kherson1032550%
Krasnodar region612350%
Black Sea1408643%
Mykolaiv704343%
Zaporizhzhia2057840%
Railways823338%
Kharkiv433251535%
Lviv604233%
Odesa23313730%
Poltava1153327%
Strikes on oil refineries and depots25316624%
Peace talks301112723%
Strikes on energy infrastructure351116823%
NATO1136218%
Sumy1145218%
Dnipro1228217%
Bryansk region632117%
Kyiv742342912%
Moscow and Moscow region19116211%
Drones over Europe122918%
Military and financial aid to Ukraine169616%
Sanctions85300%
Crimea64200%
Mobilisation52300%
Chernihiv40400%
Prisoner exchanges43100%
Belgorod region31200%

Latest cards where the versions contradict

Method

How it works: a language model sets the label together with the card text (for older cards, in a separate pass over the finished text), using only the reports collected in the card. “Agree” — the groups report the same core facts; “differ in details” — the same event, but figures, details, the description of the target, attribution or omissions differ; “contradict each other” — incompatible accounts of a core fact (who struck whom or what, opposite statements, clearly different figures for the same thing). The label does not say who is right. Cards with only one group’s version are not labelled.